depends really on what you're after. simply put, blizzard has adjusted all crafting professions across the board so they all provide the same bonus to each stat, which pretty much leaves you at the point of asking yourself "where do i want to save/make money from?" or "what additional benefits do i want in pvp" personally i'm alchemy/herbalism as you can make a decent profit with elixir mastery and a great saving on pots and flasks for raids/day to day usage, and then from herbalism having the bonus of lifebood which is a pretty sweet heal. other professions have other benefits so really u've gotta research them and then decide urself. regardless there is no bad combination