Let me start out by saying I am fairly new at paladin healing. Originally I had her a tank, but due to guild shortage of healers, I dualspecced to holy. I have a disc priest that heals just fine, but I don't want my pally collecting dust, so I gave holy a shot.
I read the sticky at the top, but I think I am following that pretty closely. I do forget to judge a lot still, but I don't believe that failure to judge is whats making me suck so badly. I'm not really sure if its bad choice of heals, or bad gear, or just me failing at pally healing.
I keep Sacred Shield up on the tank, and Beacon of Light. When I remember to judge, I use JoW (its what I'm glyphed for). I generally use Holy Shock as much as I can,then Flash of Light, and Holy Light for big heals. I try to work in Divine Illumination and Divine Favor in when I can/need them.
My problem is not going OOM, but not being able to keep people up, including the tank, especially with AOE damage. Like I said, I am not experienced with pally healing, so my examples are H Nexus and reg ToC. I did fine in Nexus until Grand Magus Telestra, which I repeatedly failed at. I brought in my priest and did just fine. The other Nexus bosses I healed fine as a pally. In ToC, I can't make it past the first encounter right after the dismount (yes I'm re-equipping my weapon). Again I brought my priest and did just fine. I can't figure out what I am doing wrong.
My pally is not geared quite as well as my priest, but not terribly (though I know, I know, I need some trinkets). Here is a link to my armory:
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Ysera&n=Anawen
The spec, I took from a friend, who seems to do really well healing.
On a side note, both tanks I was healing were not defense capped, but getting close. (a paladin in Nexus, a DK in ToC). I know this might have something to do with it, but like I said, my priest did fine.
I also use Flask of the Frost Wyrm and spellpower buff food for added help. Apparently its not enough, haha.
I would really appreciate any advice I could get, and I do apologize if this was addressed somewhere else.
Edited, Aug 6th 2009 4:26pm by Chlore