kingpatzer wrote:
1500 SP is not going to be enough to heal an equally geared tank in any heroic with any group make-up.
It will be enough to heal a tank in better gear than you in a heroic, or through a heroic with CC options tuned for that heroic.
So it doesn't mean you shouldn't be in heroics, but it does mean that if you're going in with tanks who are at your same gear level you will struggle -- particularly on any of the harder one's.
Sorry, but that's just incorrect at every turn. I started healing heroics alongside an equally-geared tank that I had leveled through Northrend with. We hit 80 together and went into heroics together armed with nothing but 75-80 quest and instance blues. I had around 1250 SP unbuffed, no more.
The only time we struggled was when we were in parties with less than 4.5k collective DPS because things took forever to die. In other words,
we were fine and it was the DPS that was dragging
us down when they didn't pull their weight.
Skilled players who have put in the necessary work to get the gear appropriate to run their current tier of content can do it with the bare minimum. You don't need a Naxx-geared tank with 28k unbuffed life to come in and baby you. In fact, you don't need a single player with a single epic, badge or raid, to run a heroic. All gear does, past the bare minimum, is increase your margin for error.
Unfortunately, since you generally can't count on four other people to be as equally skilled and geared as you are, that increased margin is often necessary to compensate for the increased error. This is true of guilds and even more true of pugs. That's where this grossly inflated sense of expectation comes from, and unfortunately, the ignorant masses tend to cast that responsibility entirely on the tank and the healer.
It's sad that a few of us have to suffer for the shortcomings of the vast majority. Sad, but true.